Alex. Charming, smart, beautiful, willful, volatile. Able to wake the whole house in a single shriek.
It has been about a month since we decided to ferberize Alex. The short and unexpected story is that he still wakes several times night while Jon, with no intervention on our part, sleeps soundly from evening until morning.
Here’s the longer story.
I decided to re-read parts of Ferber’s book before withholding Alex’s nighttime milk supply, and letting him, and us, cope with the consequences. Ferberizing has such a bad reputation, but some of his advice is quite reasonable, even moderate. For children like Alex, who drink several bottles or nurse several times a night, Ferber suggests that cold-turkey is too radical. Rather, the amount of milk in the bottle, or the time spent nursing should be reduced gradually over the course of a week or two. He maintains that too much milk interferes with sound sleep, and therefore if babies drink less throughout the night, they will start to sleep better and longer.
Alex is quite particular. We usually give him a warm, five-ounce bottle at night. If his bottle is cold, or half-full, or, god forbid, contains water, it gets thrown with complete contempt to the other end of the crib. He’s not spoiled, at least not during the day. He listens to “no”, he waits, he is learning to share. Anything to do with sleep, however, seems to bring out his worst, or perhaps his most insecure. Nonetheless, we decided to try Ferber’s approach.
We cut his milk to four ounces the first night. The bottle was drunk, not thrown. So far, so good. After another two nights, we gave him only three ounces. Miraculously, he didn’t balk. In fact, after several nights at three ounces, he slept for six straight hours and consumed only three ounces during the entire night. That’s twelve ounces less than his usual nighttime fare. We were making progress.
Life intervened. After giving Alex slightly less than three ounces one evening, I went to bed, expecting all to be quiet. Instead, he started to cry. Not his I-want-more-milk cry, but a deeper and more urgent cry. He had thrown up all three ounces and more. He was clearly ill for only 24 hours, but he was more subtly distressed – clingy and irritable – for about ten days. I couldn’t add to his misery by further reducing his nightly comfort food. I did try watering down his milk, another of Ferber’s suggestions. Alex took one sip of his homemade skim milk and the bottle went flying…. So here we are. He still wakes up twice a night on average – sometimes only once, sometimes three times. He still gets, and gulps, three ounces each time.
Now that Alex is well and my husband is home (he was away on business during the events of the last paragraph) we will continue to wean Alex from his nocturnal milk dependency. I doubt that it will be easy. Although he is drinking less at night, he still relies on a bottle to go back to sleep. Three ounces to zero will be a big step.
Luckily, thankfully, Jon has decided not only to sleep in his crib, but to sleep through the entire night. We didn’t force it, or even plan it. The only explanations I have are: (1) Jon has a calmer, more even temper than Alex; (2) Jon finishes all of Alex’s food and bottles during the day; and (3) he’s seventeen months old. Really, it has to happen sometime.