Toddlers are picky eaters

Not exactly a news flash. Parenting magazines write about it; baby food companies exploit it. Unfortunately, neither vitamin-enhanced toddler formula nor stealthily hidden vegetables will change the fact that toddlers generally eat what they want, and toss the rest to the floor – or to some well-fed family pet.

Thomas is our most mercurial eater. He has a ten meter anti-veggie-radar and extensive, apparently innate, knowledge of the supermarket snack food aisle. At times he seems to survive on milk, bread and hope for sweets, all other offerings being refused with tremendous drama. At other times, he will relish an apple, orange or soft-boiled egg as the most delectable treat.

When Thomas was about two and a half, we lost patience with his fussiness and our consequent evening routine (I make dinner; Thomas refuses it; Thomas is hungry and we are both awake by 3 am). We adopted a rather merciless alternative. Thomas must now finish all of his dinner or he sits in his “time out” place on the stairs. This was hell at first. Mealtimes became a very loud, stressful, unpleasant struggle, and Thomas spent a lot of time on the stairs. Within a few days, however, he learned to try what was in front of him, and more often than not, he liked it. He has since eaten salmon, stir-fry, curried chicken, veggie pancakes and everything else I have made for dinner.

I never thought I would resort to such tactics. I hate the thought of mixing healthy eating with punishment. Ideally, I would respect our children’s preferences, encourage them to eat when they are hungry, and foster a relaxed but adventuresome attitude toward food. Maybe this will come – but not during toddlerhood. For now, we have set our goals on a few more basic and realistic lessons:

  • We eat – or at least try – what has been made.
  • We sit together at the table for meals.
  • There are consequences for bad behaviour.
  • Mom and Dad determine what is, and what isn’t bad behaviour.

Alex and Jon haven’t yet been subjected to this regime. I think they’re too young for “time out” and they’re are not as choosy as Thomas. Alex will try everything and rejects little. He seems too eager to get on with life to linger over meals. He just fuels up and runs. Jon more obviously savours his meals, often using all six senses to explore his food. The result is a fabulous mess and a more discerning eater. He has a sweet-tooth (inherited from his mother) but will happily smear his body with plain yogurt, hummus, watermelon, and veggie burgers.

Here’s a quick list of the toddler foods that have worked best for us:

Plain yogurt. It’s cheaper than flavoured and I can control the amount of sugar by serving it plain or with molasses or fruit.

Organic raisins. Alex eats them by the handful. Grapes, and therefore raisins, can have high pesticide residues so I try to buy organic. See the Environmental Working Group’s Shoppers Guide.

Peanuts and cashews. High in fat and protein but allergenic. I give them to Thomas but not yet to the twins.

Fruit. Any type, but watermelon and apple sauce are most popular.

Hummus. High in protein, easy and cheap to make (although I usually just buy it).

Lasagna. Particularly good for hiding vegetables.

Eggs. Soft-boiled for Thomas; scrambled for the twins. This is our default dinner when there’s nothing else in the house.

As for recipe books, my two favourites are:

Rebar. From the Victoria, BC restaurant by the same name. The recipes are not quick-and-easy but I have made almost one third of the recipes in this book and they are all excellent and mostly kid-friendly.

The Best Vegetable Recipes. From the editors of Cook’s Illustrated. Turns out that vegetables taste much better if they are cooked properly. This book shows you how.

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati

3 Responses to “Toddlers are picky eaters”


  1. 1 Doug Cress

    I was a very picky-eater growing up as well - it was troublesome for me at times - my family was sometimes hard on me.

    I’ve done a little research and recently wrote up a cursory overview on the subject at BlogSoop.

    http://www.blogsoop.com/blog/a-scientific-exploration-of-picky-eaters/

    I’m sure your toddler will grow out of it. It took me sometime before I realized its just food.

  2. 2 Kim

    Great article! Even more fun than a picky toddler are picky toddler twins - and not picky about the same things of course! That would be too easy. I find things change from week to week . Sometimes bananas are a big hit - other times they won’t touch them. Applesauce is usually a good one although occasionally they like to use it to cement thing to my kitchen table. That and oatmeal. When they were younger they’d rub it in their hair for fun. Sigh.

    I’ve learned that they won’t starve - even if it seems like they’re not eating much. My daughter is pretty much a 3 year old vegetarian but loves broccoli so we compromise and have broccoli and soy nuts for protein. Her twin usually eats anything but lately has been very picky. Our option for not eating what is served? An apple. If you don’t eat dinner you may have an apple - or nothing. They usually pick apple and the rest of the family enjoys some variety in their meals!

  3. 3 twinutero

    Hi Kim,
    The apple is a great idea and raising-twins.com is a great site. Very cute photos! I’ve added a link.

Leave a Reply